Shelter Island hotels: get the best Shelter Island hotel deal by cheap rates. No booking fees. You pay for the hotel room in Shelter Island at the check-out. Free cancellation.

Shelter Island hotel reservation: check availability and room rates
Select date

Select date

Ages of children:

Shelter Island hotels & apartments, all accommodations in Shelter Island

Recommended hotels in Shelter Island

  • Sunset Beach photo

    Sunset Beach

    Sunset Beach is a 4-star exquisite hotel providing a modern accommodation only minutes away from Gin Beach, Railroad Museum of Long Island and Mashomack Preserve. The hotel opened its doors in 1970 and was remodeled in 2010.

  • The Pridwin Hotel photo

    The Pridwin Hotel

    Featuring an outdoor swimming pool, a spa center and a tennis court, the 3-star The Pridwin Hotel offers 40 en-suite guestrooms.

We offer 2 hotels in Shelter Island USA with low rates and discounts. Our reservation system provides cheap and luxury hotels in Shelter Island, hostels, motels, B&B and other budget accommodation in Shelter Island. We have excellent hotel deals in central Shelter Island. You can also book Shelter Island airport hotels at low prices. Our system is secure and absolutely charge-free.

Shelter Island map